Skip to Main Content
amish furniture blog header

Pros and Cons of Amish Furniture

by Nick, Digital Specialist | November 1, 2023

Amish furniture is renowned for its quality, craftsmanship, and elegant simplicity. However, there are some things to consider before making a large investment. What are the pros and cons?


When most people think of "Amish" furniture, they think of quality. It considered some of the highest-quality furniture available, and rightfully so. Amish furniture manufacturers focus on the way their furniture is built and the materials they use, resulting in a fine piece of furniture that results in long-lasting durability. This has many clear advantages, but there are some disadvantages to consider as well before making your decision.

amish dining

Pros

  • Quality. Amish furniture is built with longevity in mind. They are careful to use materials and construction techniques that ensure that your piece can be an heirloom- that it won't need to be replaced for a really long time. The lumber they use is sustainably sourced from local forests near their factory. In addition, the artisans that are building these pieces have learned their skills from others who have passed their knowledge down through generations.

  • Timeless aesthetic. Amish furniture is not ornate or gaudy; it has a simple beauty with clean lines that can blend with many other styles. Their classic designs are versatile and adaptable to other styles and pieces. In addition, each piece will be unique- it may have knots, wormholes, or other features that are unique to that piece. You certainly won't have to worry about having the same piece as your neighbor. Just be aware that it might not look exactly like the model you see on the floor!

  • Customizability. Because of the hand-crafted and made-to-order nature of Amish furniture, they have the ability to customize it. Many times, you'll have the option of choosing different finishes, styles, hardware, and much more. The final result will be something truly unique and perfect for your home and your style.

  • Made in the USA. Predominantly located in Amish and Mennonite communities in Pennsylvania, Ohio, Indiana, and Michigan, the wood shops that produce this furniture use sustainably sourced lumber from local forests. Buying Amish furniture ensures that you are supporting American industry, as well as local jobs and manufacturing.

amish bedroom

Cons

  • Price. Due to its quality and handmade nature, Amish furniture will be inherently more expensive. This is the opposite of one of those mass-produced sets that you find in every store. The craftsmen and craftswomen have taken years to hone their craft, and the materials are sourced from local forests. That's not to say you don't get what you pay for- Amish furniture represents an incredible value, considering its durability, utility, and simple beauty. However, the price tag is not for everyone.

  • Time. We mentioned customizability above as an advantage- but that comes with a cost. If you are in need of a dining set right away, an Amish set will not be the right choice. Because each piece is hand-crafted to order, plan on your order taking several weeks before it arrives in your home. The wait will certainly be worth it- as long as you can afford to wait!

  • Weight. If you're the kind of person who likes to re-decorate their home all the time, Amish furniture may not be the right choice. Their use of solid hardwoods such as maple, oak, elm, cherry or walnut means that the pieces will weigh a lot. Unless you enjoy hiring professional movers each time you get the itch to rearrange your room, you might want to consider another type of furniture.